Skip to content
Free Demand Writer
Menu
Free Demand Writer

Free COBRA Notice Violation Demand Letter

A COBRA notice violation letter goes to a former employer and its health plan administrator when a worker or family member lost group health coverage and never received a proper notice of the right to continue it. It asks the plan to fix the notice failure, restore the chance to elect coverage, and cover the losses that followed.

Free Demand Writer reads the plan documents, notices and medical bills you upload and drafts an editable Word letter. It lays out the qualifying event and the notice history in date order, cites each fact to its file and page, totals uninsured costs as read, and marks every penalty, deadline and coverage rule [VERIFY] for your attorney to confirm.

New to this kind of letter? Our guide explains what goes into a demand letter, when to send one and what happens next.

  • Free
  • No sign-up
  • Editable Word (.docx)
  • Files deleted after drafting

When to use this letter

Use this letter when a client lost employer health coverage and the records suggest the continuation notice was missing, late or defective. Typical cases:

  • A former employee was terminated or had hours cut and never received an election notice.
  • The notice went to an old address the employer knew was out of date.
  • A spouse or dependent lost coverage after a divorce or the employee's death and was never told of the right to continue.
  • The client tried to elect coverage and the plan or administrator refused or never processed it.
  • The client paid large medical bills while uninsured because the coverage gap was never explained.

The federal COBRA law may apply to many group health plans, and some states have their own continuation laws for smaller employers. Who must send which notice, and when, depends on the plan and the law. The draft does not decide coverage, deadlines or penalties; your attorney does.

What to upload

Upload up to 5 PDFs, 500 pages in total. The notice history carries this letter, so include anything showing what was sent, when and to which address.

Plan records
The summary plan description, enrollment confirmations and benefits statements showing who was covered and under which plan.
Separation or qualifying event records
The termination letter, hours change notice, divorce decree or death certificate that set the date coverage ended.
Notices received
Any election notice, coverage termination letter or administrator correspondence, with envelopes or postmarks if kept.
Address and contact history
Change-of-address forms, emails or HR records that show where the employer knew the client lived.
Medical bills and premiums
Bills incurred during the gap and the cost of any replacement coverage the client bought.

What the draft includes

An editable Word letter built only from what your documents say. Missing facts become [ADD: …] placeholders, never guesses, and any law cited is marked [VERIFY].

  1. Please verify box. A short notice at the top reminding the reviewer that this is an unverified AI draft.
  2. Coverage summary. The plan, the covered family members and the date coverage ended, as the records show them.
  3. Notice timeline. A table of the qualifying event, any notice to the administrator and each notice sent or received, cited to the page.
  4. Gaps in the record. Where the records are silent about a notice, the draft adds an [ADD: …] placeholder instead of assuming.
  5. Losses table. Uninsured medical bills and replacement coverage costs, with dates, amounts and sources, and the total as read.
  6. The demand. A corrected election notice or reinstatement, reimbursement, the amount and the deadline. Amount and deadline are placeholders.
  7. Preservation request. A request that the employer and administrator keep plan documents, notice logs and mailing records.

Before you send it

The result is an unverified AI draft for attorney review, not legal advice.

  • Confirm whether the plan is covered by federal COBRA, a state continuation law or both.
  • Check the notice deadlines, the penalty rules and whether a court must award any penalty.
  • Identify the correct plan administrator and send the letter to the right party.
  • Set the amount and deadline, and remove the Please verify box.

Common mistakes

COBRA notice claims turn on who had the duty to send what, and on proof of mailing. These errors weaken the letter.

  • Writing only to the employer The employer and the plan administrator can have different notice duties. Name each party the documents show, and check who is responsible for each notice.
  • Assuming no notice was sent The client may not remember a letter, and the administrator may have mailing logs. Say what the records show, not more.
  • Stating a penalty figure Penalty amounts and whether they apply at all depend on the law and often on a court. Leave them for your attorney to assess.
  • Ignoring state continuation laws Smaller employers may fall under a state law instead of the federal one. Check before naming the law that applies.
  • Missing the plan's claim procedure Some plans require an internal appeal before a lawsuit. Read the plan documents for claim and appeal steps.

Free cobra notice violation demand letter template

Prefer to write it yourself? Download a plain Word template with fields to fill in. No AI, no email needed. Sample template, not legal advice.

Questions

Is the COBRA notice violation demand letter free?

Yes. No account and no payment.

Will it calculate statutory penalties?

No. The draft totals the uninsured costs the records show and leaves any penalty as an [ADD: …] placeholder for your attorney.

Who should the letter go to?

Usually the former employer and the plan administrator. The draft names both if the documents show them, and adds a placeholder if the administrator is not named.

Does it cover state continuation laws?

It flags them. Some states have their own continuation rules for smaller employers, and the draft marks that point [VERIFY] for your attorney to check.

What happens to the documents I upload?

They are deleted as soon as the draft is generated. The Word file is deleted after 48 hours or 3 downloads.

Fictional sample

See a sample draft

We made up a case file and ran it through Free Demand Writer, the same way your documents would be. This is the unedited draft. Everything in it is fictional: the people, the companies and the facts. A West Virginia office manager was laid off and her family's group health coverage ended, but no continuation election notice ever reached the new address she had given HR, and her husband's emergency surgery during the gap went uninsured.

Fictional case file: layoff_and_enrollment_records.pdf, address_change_and_emails.pdf, medical_bills_and_premiums.pdf · State: West Virginia

Page 1 of a fictional sample cobra notice violation demand letter drafted by Free Demand Writer Download sample PDF

Fictional sample. Not legal advice. Your draft is built from your own documents.

Fictional sample · letter text

PLEASE VERIFY BEFORE SENDING

Unverified AI draft. Every fact must be checked against the records before use. It is not legal advice. Fill in every [ADD: …] placeholder, set the demand amount, confirm anything marked [VERIFY], and delete this box before sending.

  • Representation: the firm notes name only Jennifer Coyle as the client. The hospital bills are for her spouse, Thomas Coyle, who was also a covered person. Confirm whether the firm also represents him and who the payee of any reimbursement should be.
  • Keystone Benefit Administrators Inc. is identified only by the benefits portal contacts page [layoff_and_enrollment_records.pdf p.1]. Confirm who the formal plan administrator is (Bluegrove or Keystone as a third-party administrator). Keystone's address and contact, Bluegrove's ZIP code, and the claim/account number are not in the records.
  • The records do not show when Bluegrove notified Keystone of the qualifying event, or how Keystone came to use the 77 Sycamore Lane address after HR approved the address change on August 5, 2025. Both are left as placeholders.
  • The returned envelope is a copy supplied by the client's former neighbor [address_change_and_emails.pdf p.1]. Confirm its authenticity, when it was returned, and that the client received no notice after her October 21, 2025 email.
  • The election period end date is not in the records. Ms. Allard's November 18, 2025 email says only that it "has now closed," and the letter does not state a date.
  • The total of $40,273.45 is my addition of the amounts as read: $31,994.45 + $4,650.00 + $185.00 + $3,444.00. Please check it. The medical figures are billed charges, not amounts the plan would have paid. Premiums after the February 2, 2026 statement are not included and may need updating.
  • [VERIFY] items for federal COBRA law, notice deadlines and penalties, and West Virginia state continuation law (including whether Bluegrove's size matters) are unresolved. No statute or deadline is stated in the letter.
  • The demand amount, response deadline, statutory penalties, letter date, delivery method and firm contact details are placeholders. Hospital and provider account numbers were left out on purpose.
  • The firm notes give the client's preferred remedy as reinstatement to October 1, 2025 or reimbursement. Confirm that framing, and whether Bluegrove or the plan can legally reinstate retroactively.

Prewitt Calloway PLLC
[ADD: firm street address]
[ADD: city, state ZIP]
[ADD: phone] · [ADD: email]

[ADD: date]

VIA [ADD: delivery method]

Marcy Allard, HR Director
Bluegrove Dental Partners LLC
1420 Tobacco Barn Road
Linden Falls, West Virginia [ADD: ZIP]

[ADD: Keystone recipient name]
Keystone Benefit Administrators Inc.
[ADD: street address]
[ADD: city, state ZIP]

Re: Failure to provide continuation coverage election notice. Jennifer Coyle. Bluegrove Dental Partners Group Health Plan. Claim/account number [ADD: claim or account number]. Coverage ended September 30, 2025

Dear Marcy Allard and [ADD: Keystone recipient name]:

Introduction

We represent Jennifer Coyle, who was covered under Bluegrove Dental Partners LLC's group health plan until September 30, 2025 [layoff_and_enrollment_records.pdf p.1]. This letter demands that Bluegrove Dental Partners LLC ("Bluegrove") and Keystone Benefit Administrators Inc. ("Keystone") correct the failure to deliver continuation coverage election information to Ms. Coyle and pay the losses that followed.

Coverage and qualifying event

Ms. Coyle was enrolled in the Bluegrove Dental Partners Group Health Plan, PPO Silver option, at the "employee plus spouse" tier. Coverage was effective January 1, 2025 and covered Ms. Coyle and her spouse, Thomas Coyle [layoff_and_enrollment_records.pdf p.1]. The 2025 enrollment confirmation lists Keystone as the plan administrator for COBRA continuation, as shown on the benefits portal contacts page [layoff_and_enrollment_records.pdf p.1].

By letter dated September 12, 2025, Bluegrove told Ms. Coyle that her Office Manager position was eliminated, that her last day of employment was September 19, 2025, and that her group medical, dental and vision coverage would end on September 30, 2025. The letter also said that information about continuing her health coverage "will be mailed to you separately by our plan administrator" [layoff_and_enrollment_records.pdf p.1]. The insurer portal shows Mr. Coyle's coverage as terminated effective September 30, 2025, with the reason "Employment ended" [layoff_and_enrollment_records.pdf p.1].

Notice timeline

DateEventSource
August 4, 2025Ms. Coyle submitted a home address change through the Bluegrove HR portal, from 77 Sycamore Lane, Ashby, to 310 Quarry Hill Court, Linden Falls[address_change_and_emails.pdf p.1]
August 5, 2025M. Allard approved the address change[address_change_and_emails.pdf p.1]
September 12, 2025Bluegrove layoff letter; coverage to end September 30, 2025; continuation information to be mailed by the plan administrator[layoff_and_enrollment_records.pdf p.1]
September 19, 2025Last day of employment. Ms. Coyle emailed Ms. Allard asking her to confirm the COBRA paperwork would go to the Quarry Hill Court address[layoff_and_enrollment_records.pdf p.1]; [address_change_and_emails.pdf p.1]
September 22, 2025Ms. Allard replied: "Yes, Keystone will mail it. Let me know if you don't get it."[address_change_and_emails.pdf p.1]
September 30, 2025Group coverage ended[layoff_and_enrollment_records.pdf p.1]
[ADD: date Bluegrove notified the plan administrator of the qualifying event]Employer notice to the plan administrator (not shown in the records)[ADD: source]
October 2, 2025Keystone envelope postmarked, addressed to Ms. Coyle at 77 Sycamore Lane, Ashby. It was stamped "Return to sender, not at this address" and never forwarded to Ms. Coyle[address_change_and_emails.pdf p.1]
October 14, 2025Mr. Coyle underwent emergency surgery[address_change_and_emails.pdf p.1]; [medical_bills_and_premiums.pdf p.1]
October 21, 2025Ms. Coyle emailed Ms. Allard that she had not received anything about continuing coverage, that the hospital reported no insurance, and asked that the election form be sent that day[address_change_and_emails.pdf p.1]
October 30, 2025Ms. Allard replied that Keystone said a packet was mailed October 2 "to the address on file," and that she would ask which address Keystone had[address_change_and_emails.pdf p.1]
November 18, 2025Ms. Allard wrote that Keystone said the packet went to 77 Sycamore Lane, Ashby, and that the election period "has now closed"[address_change_and_emails.pdf p.1]
[ADD: date election period ended, per Keystone]End of election period as asserted by Keystone[ADD: source]

The records show no election notice reaching Ms. Coyle at her Quarry Hill Court address as of her October 21, 2025 email [address_change_and_emails.pdf p.1]. [ADD: whether any election notice was received by Ms. Coyle after October 21, 2025]

Bluegrove approved the Quarry Hill Court address on August 5, 2025, and Ms. Allard acknowledged Ms. Coyle's September 19 request about where the paperwork should go. The only notice Keystone is known to have sent went to the old address [address_change_and_emails.pdf p.1]. [ADD: how and when Bluegrove gave Keystone Ms. Coyle's address information]

Harm to our client

Ms. Coyle's husband received emergency care beginning October 14, 2025, after her group coverage had ended and before she had any opportunity to elect continuation coverage. The hospital statement shows insurance payments of $0.00 and a self-pay balance, and the surgeon's statement notes "No active coverage found for date of service. Account placed on self-pay." [medical_bills_and_premiums.pdf p.1]. The Coyles then bought replacement individual coverage through Riverbend Health Plan of West Virginia, effective December 1, 2025, at $1,148.00 per month [medical_bills_and_premiums.pdf p.1].

ItemDateAmountSource
Central Valley Regional Medical Center, total charges (emergency department, imaging, surgical services, anesthesia, inpatient room and board, pharmacy and supplies); balance due, self-payOctober 14 to October 17, 2025 (statement dated November 20, 2025)$31,994.45[medical_bills_and_premiums.pdf p.1]
Linden Falls Surgical Associates, surgeon feeOctober 14, 2025$4,650.00[medical_bills_and_premiums.pdf p.1]
Linden Falls Surgical Associates, follow-up visitOctober 31, 2025$185.00[medical_bills_and_premiums.pdf p.1]
Riverbend Health Plan of West Virginia, replacement premiums paid for December 2025, January 2026 and February 2026December 2025 to February 2026 (total paid as of February 2, 2026)$3,444.00[medical_bills_and_premiums.pdf p.1]
Total (as read from the bills)$40,273.45

Premiums for later months, and any further charges from these providers, are not included. [ADD: any additional bills or premiums incurred after February 2, 2026]

Demand

On behalf of Ms. Coyle, we demand that Bluegrove and Keystone do the following:

  • Provide Ms. Coyle a compliant election notice for continuation coverage, sent to 310 Quarry Hill Court, Linden Falls, West Virginia, and reinstate her and Thomas Coyle's coverage under the plan retroactive to October 1, 2025, so that the October 2025 hospital and surgical bills are processed as covered claims [firm notes].
  • In the alternative, reimburse Ms. Coyle and Mr. Coyle for the medical bills listed above and for the replacement coverage premiums paid, and any later premiums, as set out in the table above [firm notes].
  • Pay [ADD: demand amount].
  • Pay [ADD: statutory penalties, if any].
  • Provide copies of the October 2, 2025 notice packet, any notice sent to the plan administrator of the qualifying event, and the address information Bluegrove gave Keystone.
  • Respond in writing by [ADD: response deadline].

We also ask that Bluegrove and Keystone preserve all plan documents, notices and notice logs, mailing and returned-mail records, address records for Ms. Coyle, and communications about her coverage, including emails with Ms. Allard and Keystone's records of the October 2, 2025 mailing.

Federal and state rules

The federal law on continuation of group health coverage (COBRA) may apply to the Bluegrove plan [VERIFY]. The federal rules on the deadlines for employer and administrator notices, the election period, and available penalties are [VERIFY: federal rule on COBRA notice deadlines and penalties]. West Virginia may also have its own continuation coverage requirements for some employers [VERIFY: West Virginia rule on state continuation coverage]. Ms. Coyle reserves all rights and remedies under federal and state law, including as to Mr. Coyle.

Please direct all communications about this matter to my attention.

Sincerely,

Nathaniel R. Prewitt
Prewitt Calloway PLLC