Defective Software / SaaS SLA Breach Demand Letter: How the law works
Last verified: Nov 22, 2026 · Sources checked automatically
The short answer
In California, a court reads a contract to give effect to what both sides intended when they signed it, so far as that can be worked out and is lawful. The written terms of a software or SaaS agreement (service levels, remedies and so on) are the starting point. CIV 1636 (opens in a new tab)
If a contract is breached, damages are meant to compensate for the harm the breach caused. They cannot exceed what the injured party would have gained if the contract had been fully performed. CIV 3300 (opens in a new tab), CIV 3358 (opens in a new tab)
A contract may set the damages in advance ("liquidated damages"). Whether that clause holds up depends on the type of contract. For a four-year filing period, a written contract falls under the rule in Code of Civil Procedure section 337. CIV 1671 (opens in a new tab), CCP 337 (opens in a new tab)
How these disputes usually work
A dispute usually starts when the customer notices the software is failing or the service is down and reports it to the provider, often following the steps in the agreement. If the problem is not fixed, the customer may send a written demand letter that describes the problem, points to the contract terms and asks for a remedy such as a credit, a refund or repair. The provider may reply, dispute the facts or the contract's meaning, or negotiate a settlement, and the parties may move to a formal process if they cannot agree.
Contract terms to look for
- Service level commitments and how uptime is measured
- Service credits or other stated remedies
- Notice and cure requirements
- Limitation of liability and damage exclusions
- Liquidated damages or early termination fees
- Termination and refund rights
- Dispute resolution, arbitration or venue clauses
- Warranty disclaimers and support obligations
General law that applies
-
How a contract is interpreted
A contract is read to carry out the shared intention the parties had when they made it, as far as that can be found and is lawful.
Exact words from the statute
A contract must be so interpreted as to give effect to the mutual intention of the parties as it existed at the time of contracting, so far as the same is ascertainable and lawful.
-
How damages for breach are measured
Unless the Code says otherwise, damages are the amount that compensates the injured party for the harm the breach proximately caused (that is, directly caused).
Exact words from the statute
the measure of damages, except where otherwise expressly provided by this Code, is the amount which will compensate the party aggrieved for all the detriment proximately caused thereby
-
Cap on what can be recovered
Except where a statute says otherwise, a person cannot recover more than they would have gained if the contract had been fully performed by both sides.
Exact words from the statute
no person can recover a greater amount in damages for the breach of an obligation, than he could have gained by the full performance thereof on both sides.
-
Liquidated damages clauses in most contracts
A clause that sets damages in advance is generally valid. The party challenging it must show it was unreasonable under the circumstances when the contract was made.
Exact words from the statute
a provision in a contract liquidating the damages for the breach of the contract is valid unless the party seeking to invalidate the provision establishes that the provision was unreasonable under the circumstances existing at the time the contract was made.
-
Who gets a stricter liquidated damages test
A stricter test applies when the damages are sought from someone who bought or rented personal property or services mainly for personal, family or household purposes.
Exact words from the statute
A party to a contract for the retail purchase, or rental, by such party of personal property or services, primarily for the party’s personal, family, or household purposes
-
Liquidated damages in consumer contracts
In those consumer cases the clause is void, except that the parties may agree on an amount presumed to be the actual damage when the actual damage would be impracticable or extremely difficult to fix.
Exact words from the statute
a provision in a contract liquidating damages for the breach of the contract is void except that the parties to such a contract may agree therein upon an amount
-
Time limit for suing on a written contract
An action on a contract or obligation founded on a written instrument must be brought within four years.
Exact words from the statute
Within four years: (a) An action upon any contract, obligation or liability founded upon an instrument in writing
