Skip to content
Free Demand Writer
Menu
Free Demand Writer

Free Subrogation Demand Letter

A subrogation demand letter is sent by an insurer, or the insurer's counsel, to the at-fault party or its liability insurer. It asks them to repay what the insurer paid its policyholder for a loss they caused. It needs clear liability facts, an exact record of payments, and the basis for the insurer's right to recover.

Free Demand Writer reads the loss reports, payment records, policy and correspondence you upload and drafts an editable Word letter. It tables the payments as read, cites each fact to its file and page, and leaves the demand amount, deadline and state-specific rules for your attorney.

New to this kind of letter? Our guide explains what goes into a demand letter, when to send one and what happens next.

  • Free
  • No sign-up
  • Editable Word (.docx)
  • Files deleted after drafting

When to use this letter

Use this letter when an insurer has paid a claim and wants to recover the payments from the party responsible. Typical cases:

  • Auto property damage and collision payments after another driver caused the crash.
  • Property claims for fire, water or other damage caused by a contractor, neighbor or product.
  • Medical payments or personal injury protection benefits paid after a third party caused the injury.
  • Health plan or workers' compensation recovery from a liability carrier.
  • Recovery of the policyholder's deductible along with the insurer's payments.

Subrogation rights depend on the policy and on state law. The made-whole doctrine, anti-subrogation rules and limits for certain coverages vary by state, and some recoveries are governed by federal law, such as self-funded employee health plans. The draft marks these for your attorney to check.

What to upload

Upload up to 5 PDFs, 500 pages in total. The payment record and the liability evidence matter most.

Loss and liability reports
Police or incident reports, cause-and-origin reports, photos and statements.
Payment records
Payment logs, check copies or claim payment summaries showing each amount and date paid.
Estimates and invoices
Repair estimates, contractor invoices and appraisals that support each payment.
Policy documents
The declarations page and the policy's subrogation clause.
Subrogation receipt
Any subrogation receipt, assignment or release signed by the policyholder.
Correspondence
Letters with the at-fault party or its insurer, for claim numbers and any liability position.

What the draft includes

An editable Word letter built only from what your documents say. Missing facts become [ADD: …] placeholders, never guesses, and any law cited is marked [VERIFY].

  1. Please verify box. A short notice at the top reminding the reviewer that this is an unverified AI draft.
  2. Parties and claim numbers. The insurer as subrogee of its insured, the recipient and both claim numbers, filled in where the documents show them.
  3. The loss and liability. How the loss happened and why the recipient is responsible, with sources such as [police_report.pdf p.2].
  4. Payments table. Each payment by payee and date as read, with the deductible listed separately and a total for you to confirm.
  5. Subrogation rights. The policy clause and any signed receipt or assignment, cited, plus a [VERIFY] note on your state's rules.
  6. Preservation request. A request to keep evidence of the loss.
  7. The demand. The amount, response deadline and payment instructions are placeholders.

Before you send it

The result is an unverified AI draft for attorney review, not legal advice.

  • Reconcile the payments table with the payment log and confirm the total.
  • Decide whether the demand includes the policyholder's deductible.
  • Check your state's made-whole and anti-subrogation rules for this coverage.
  • Check whether the claim belongs in an intercompany arbitration program instead.
  • Fill in every [ADD: …] placeholder, set the amount and deadline, and remove the Please verify box.

Common mistakes

Liability carriers handle subrogation demands in volume. These are the reasons they set them aside.

  • Payments that don't reconcile If the letter, the payment log and the invoices show different totals, expect the lowest figure or a request for proof. Match each payment to its record.
  • No proof of subrogation rights Attach the policy clause or a signed subrogation receipt. Without it, the recipient may question the insurer's standing to recover.
  • Ignoring the made-whole rule In some states the insurer cannot recover until the policyholder is fully compensated. Check the rule before you demand.
  • Losing the evidence Damaged parts and products are often discarded after repair. Preserve them, and ask the other side to preserve theirs.

Free subrogation demand letter template

Prefer to write it yourself? Download a plain Word template with fields to fill in. No AI, no email needed. Sample template, not legal advice.

Questions

Is the subrogation demand letter free?

Yes. No account and no payment.

Who is the letter from?

The insurer, or the firm as the insurer's counsel. It is addressed to the at-fault party or that party's liability insurer, never written as if the firm represents the policyholder.

Does it include the deductible?

It lists the deductible separately if the records show it, and leaves it to you to decide whether the demand includes it.

Does it check the made-whole doctrine?

No. It marks your state's made-whole and anti-subrogation rules for your attorney to verify, because they vary by state.

What happens to the documents I upload?

They are used only to draft the letter and are deleted as soon as the draft is generated. The Word file is deleted after 48 hours or 3 downloads.

Fictional sample

See a sample draft

We made up a case file and ran it through Free Demand Writer, the same way your documents would be. This is the unedited draft. Everything in it is fictional: the people, the companies and the facts. An Indiana homeowner's insurer pays for water damage after a plumbing contractor's improperly crimped supply line fails in a newly remodeled upstairs bathroom, and seeks to recover from the plumber.

Fictional case file: cause_and_origin_report.pdf, claim_payment_log.pdf, policy_and_subrogation_receipt.pdf · State: Indiana

Page 1 of a fictional sample subrogation demand letter drafted by Free Demand Writer Download sample PDF

Fictional sample. Not legal advice. Your draft is built from your own documents.

Fictional sample · letter text

PLEASE VERIFY BEFORE SENDING

Unverified AI draft. Every fact must be checked against the records before use. It is not legal advice. Fill in every [ADD: …] placeholder, set the demand amount, confirm anything marked [VERIFY], and delete this box before sending.

  • The demand amount, response deadline and payee/payment instructions are placeholders. The firm notes say the demand includes the insureds' $1,000.00 deductible and that the attorney sets the total. No combined figure appears in this draft.
  • The payment total of $44,034.30 is as read from the claim payment log. The five line items add up to that figure, but check it against the underlying invoices and checks. The deductible of $1,000.00 is shown separately, as in the log.
  • The $2,350.00 payment to Hollister Forensic Engineering is coded as "Expense" in the log. Confirm it should be included in the amount sought.
  • The sources contain only a policy excerpt, with no policy number. Confirm that the insureds did not waive recovery rights in writing before the loss, and check any remodel contract between the Novaks and Bellmont for a waiver or limitation. Neither document is in the file.
  • The Indiana made-whole, anti-subrogation and related limits are flagged [VERIFY] in the Subrogation rights section.
  • Liability rests on the Hollister report alone (one page). Bellmont's photos from the September 17, 2025 inspection, its work records and its contract are not in the sources.
  • The Crossroads claim number, policy number, adjuster name and address, and Bellmont's address are not in the sources. The file shows no response from Crossroads as of January 12, 2026. Confirm current status before sending.
  • Confirm whether intercompany arbitration applies. It is flagged in the Demand section.
  • Confirm the enclosures and the letter date, and that the letter goes to both Bellmont and Crossroads.

Gerrity Lowe & Pham LLP
[ADD: firm street address]
[ADD: city, state ZIP]
[ADD: phone] · [ADD: email]

[ADD: date]

VIA [ADD: delivery method]

Craig Bellmont, Owner
Bellmont Plumbing Services LLC
[ADD: street address]
[ADD: city, state ZIP]

[ADD: Crossroads claims representative name]
Crossroads Contractors Mutual
[ADD: street address]
[ADD: city, state ZIP]

Re: Subrogation demand. Insurer: Tri-County Hearth Insurance Company. Insureds: Raymond and Alicia Novak. Loss location: 3127 Fallow Creek Drive, Ashbury, Indiana. Date of loss: September 14, 2025. Tri-County Hearth claim no. TCH-25-118402. Crossroads claim no. [ADD: Crossroads claim number].

Dear Mr. Bellmont and [ADD: Crossroads claims representative name]:

Introduction

We represent Tri-County Hearth Insurance Company ("Tri-County Hearth") as subrogee of its insureds, Raymond and Alicia Novak, for the water loss at their home on September 14, 2025 [firm notes] [cause_and_origin_report.pdf p.1]. Tri-County Hearth's claim number is TCH-25-118402 [claim_payment_log.pdf p.1]. The Crossroads claim number is [ADD: Crossroads claim number].

Bellmont Plumbing Services LLC ("Bellmont") has told Tri-County Hearth's adjuster that it forwarded this matter to its insurer, Crossroads Contractors Mutual ("Crossroads") [policy_and_subrogation_receipt.pdf p.1]. To the extent Bellmont has not already done so, please forward this letter to Crossroads or any other liability insurer that may cover Bellmont for this loss, and ask that insurer to contact us.

The loss and liability

Bellmont remodeled the second-floor hall bathroom at the Novaks' home between August 4 and August 22, 2025. The work included new PEX supply lines to the vanity [cause_and_origin_report.pdf p.1]. The Novaks left for a weekend trip on September 12, 2025. When they returned on September 14, 2025, they found water coming through the kitchen ceiling below the bathroom [cause_and_origin_report.pdf p.1].

Kevin Marsh, PE, of Hollister Forensic Engineering inspected the property on September 17, 2025. His findings include the following:

  • The cold supply line to the vanity had separated from a brass fitting inside the vanity cabinet [cause_and_origin_report.pdf p.1].
  • The crimp ring at that fitting was not fully compressed. A go/no-go gauge would not pass over the ring, while the other crimp rings in the bathroom passed the gauge [cause_and_origin_report.pdf p.1].
  • He found no signs of freezing, corrosion or impact [cause_and_origin_report.pdf p.1].
  • Moisture readings showed that water traveled into the kitchen ceiling, kitchen cabinets and first-floor hardwood [cause_and_origin_report.pdf p.1].

Mr. Marsh concluded that the water loss was caused by an improperly crimped connection on the cold supply line installed by Bellmont [cause_and_origin_report.pdf p.1]. Bellmont is responsible for the resulting damage.

Bellmont was notified by phone on September 15, 2025 and was invited to attend the inspection. Craig Bellmont attended on September 17, 2025 and took photos [cause_and_origin_report.pdf p.1]. On December 8, 2025, Mr. Bellmont wrote to Tri-County Hearth's adjuster: "We stand behind our work. I've sent this to our insurance, Crossroads Contractors Mutual, policy number on file." [policy_and_subrogation_receipt.pdf p.1]. Tri-County Hearth had received no response from Crossroads as of January 12, 2026 [policy_and_subrogation_receipt.pdf p.1].

Payments made

Under the Novaks' homeowners policy (form HO-3), Tri-County Hearth has made the following payments for this loss [claim_payment_log.pdf p.1]:

Payee or itemDate paidAmountSource
DryRight Restoration Inc. (mitigation, dwelling)September 18, 2025$6,842.50[claim_payment_log.pdf p.1]
Raymond and Alicia Novak and Ashbury Home Builders (repairs, dwelling, less deductible)October 30, 2025$27,415.80[claim_payment_log.pdf p.1]
Hollister Forensic Engineering (expense)November 4, 2025$2,350.00[claim_payment_log.pdf p.1]
Raymond and Alicia Novak (contents: kitchen items, rug, small appliances)November 12, 2025$4,186.00[claim_payment_log.pdf p.1]
Raymond and Alicia Novak (loss of use: hotel, September 15 to October 6, 2025)November 12, 2025$3,240.00[claim_payment_log.pdf p.1]
Total (as read from the bills)$44,034.30[claim_payment_log.pdf p.1]

The dwelling payment of $27,415.80 reflects the Ashbury Home Builders invoice of $28,415.80 less the insureds' $1,000.00 deductible [claim_payment_log.pdf p.1]. The deductible is not included in the total above. Our demand does include the insureds' $1,000.00 deductible [firm notes] [policy_and_subrogation_receipt.pdf p.1]. All repair work was completed on November 26, 2025, and Tri-County Hearth expects no further payments [claim_payment_log.pdf p.1].

The claim file includes DryRight Restoration invoice DR-4471 with moisture maps and drying logs, the Ashbury Home Builders estimate and final invoice, a contents inventory signed by the insureds, a hotel folio from Ashbury Inn and Suites, and the Hollister Forensic Engineering invoice [claim_payment_log.pdf p.1]. [ADD: list of enclosures or statement that supporting documents will be provided on request]

Subrogation rights

The Tri-County Hearth homeowners policy provides that, unless an insured has waived recovery rights in writing before a loss, Tri-County Hearth "may require an assignment of rights of recovery for a loss to the extent that payment is made by us" [policy_and_subrogation_receipt.pdf p.1]. On November 20, 2025, Raymond Novak and Alicia Novak signed a Subrogation Receipt and Assignment. It assigns to Tri-County Hearth all rights, claims and interest against any person or entity responsible for the loss, to the extent of the payments made, and authorizes Tri-County Hearth to pursue recovery of the Novaks' $1,000.00 deductible on their behalf [policy_and_subrogation_receipt.pdf p.1].

[VERIFY: Indiana rules on the made-whole doctrine, the anti-subrogation rule and any limits on subrogation for this coverage]

Preservation of evidence

Please preserve, and instruct your employees, insurers and subcontractors to preserve, all evidence relating to the loss and to Bellmont's work at the Novak home. This includes:

  • Bellmont's photographs of the September 17, 2025 inspection.
  • Contracts, estimates, work orders, invoices and permits for the bathroom remodel.
  • Records identifying the personnel who installed the PEX supply lines.
  • The crimping tools and gauges used on the project, and related inspection or testing records.
  • Product and fitting purchase records.
  • All communications about the project or the loss.

The failed fitting, crimp ring and pipe section were removed, tagged and retained at the Hollister Forensic Engineering laboratory in Ashbury under evidence tag HFE-2291 [cause_and_origin_report.pdf p.1]. Please do not conduct or request any testing of those items without first giving us notice and an opportunity to attend.

Demand

Tri-County Hearth demands payment of [ADD: demand amount], which includes the insureds' $1,000.00 deductible. Please respond by [ADD: response deadline]. Payment should be made as follows: [ADD: payee and payment instructions].

[VERIFY: whether this claim should go to intercompany arbitration]

Please direct all communications about this matter to the undersigned.

Sincerely,

Michael D. Gerrity
Gerrity Lowe & Pham LLP